Skip to main content

PyPI Rust Binary Bundling

This document describes how the NoETL Rust CLI (noetl) is bundled with the Python package for PyPI distribution.

Overview​

NoETL uses setuptools-rust to compile and bundle the Rust binary during the Python package build process. When users install NoETL via pip install noetl, they automatically get both the Python library and the noetl command-line tool.

Configuration​

Build System (pyproject.toml)​

[build-system]
requires = ["setuptools>=45", "wheel"]
build-backend = "setuptools.build_meta"

[tool.setuptools.package-data]
"noetl" = ["core/ui/**/*", "database/ddl/**/*", "bin/noetl"]

[project.scripts]
noetl = "noetl.cli_wrapper:main"

Key Components:

  • Standard setuptools build (no setuptools-rust needed)
  • Binary included as package data in noetl/bin/noetl
  • Python wrapper script (noetl.cli_wrapper:main) executes the bundled binary
  • Works across all platforms where the binary is available

Why Not setuptools-rust?

  • Simpler build process (no compilation during wheel build)
  • Faster CI/CD pipelines (compile once, package many times)
  • Better control over build environment and Rust version
  • Easier to debug build issues
  • Supports cross-compilation workflows

GitHub Actions Workflow​

The build_on_release.yml workflow handles automated PyPI publishing:

- name: Install Rust toolchain
  uses: dtolnay/rust-toolchain@stable
  with:
    toolchain: 1.83

- name: Cache Cargo registry/index/build
  uses: actions/cache@v4
  # ... caching configuration

- name: Build NoETL
  run: uv build

- name: Publish to PyPI
  env:
    UV_PUBLISH_TOKEN: ${{ secrets.PYPI_TOKEN }}
  run: uv publish

Build Process​

  1. UI Build - Frontend assets compiled via Node.js/npm
  2. Rust Compilation - Cargo builds noetl binary separately in release mode
  3. Binary Packaging - Copy compiled binary to noetl/bin/ directory
  4. Python Package - Setuptools packages Python code, UI assets, and pre-compiled binary
  5. Wheel Creation - Platform-specific wheel includes binary as package data
  6. PyPI Upload - uv publish uploads wheel to PyPI

Build Flow:

# Step 1: Build UI
cd ui-src && npm ci && npm run build && cd ..
cp -R ui-src/dist/* noetl/core/ui/

# Step 2: Build Rust binary
cd noetlctl && cargo build --release && cd ..

# Step 3: Copy binary to package data
mkdir -p noetl/bin
cp noetlctl/target/release/noetl noetl/bin/noetl
chmod +x noetl/bin/noetl

# Step 4: Build Python package
uv build

# Step 5: Publish to PyPI
uv publish

Platform Support​

Current Support​

  • Linux (amd64) - Primary platform for CI/CD builds
  • macOS (arm64/x86_64) - Local development support
  • Windows - Requires additional Rust toolchain setup

Future: Multi-Platform Wheels​

For comprehensive platform coverage, consider using cibuildwheel:

- name: Build wheels
  uses: pypa/cibuildwheel@v2.22.0
  env:
    CIBW_ARCHS_LINUX: "x86_64 aarch64"
    CIBW_ARCHS_MACOS: "x86_64 arm64"
    CIBW_ARCHS_WINDOWS: "AMD64"

This would generate wheels for:

  • Linux: x86_64, aarch64
  • macOS: Intel (x86_64), Apple Silicon (arm64)
  • Windows: AMD64

Installation Behavior​

With Binary Bundling (Current)​

pip install noetl
noetl --version  # Works immediately - binary included

Without Binary Bundling (Legacy)​

pip install noetl
noetl --version  # Error: command not found
# Would need manual Rust compilation or separate binary distribution

Rust Version Requirements​

  • Minimum: Rust 1.82 (due to icu dependency requirements)
  • Recommended: Rust 1.83 (current CI/CD toolchain)
  • Update Path: Modify .github/workflows/build_on_release.yml and docker/noetl/dev/Dockerfile

Local Development​

Building with Rust Binary​

# Ensure Rust toolchain is installed
curl --proto '=https' --tlsv1.2 -sSf https://sh.rustup.rs | sh
rustup default 1.83

# Build Python package with Rust binary
uv build

# Install locally
pip install dist/noetl-*.whl

Testing Binary Integration​

# Verify binary is included
python -c "import noetl; import shutil; print(shutil.which('noetl'))"

# Test functionality
noetl --version
noetl server --help

Troubleshooting​

Build Failures​

Rust Compilation Errors:

error: failed to compile `noetl` due to Rust compiler errors
  • Verify Rust toolchain version: rustc --version
  • Update Rust: rustup update
  • Check Cargo.lock compatibility

Missing setuptools-rust:

ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'setuptools_rust'
  • Ensure build dependencies are installed: pip install setuptools-rust

Runtime Issues​

Binary Not Found After Installation:

noetl: command not found
  • Check Python bin directory is in PATH: echo $PATH
  • Verify installation: pip show noetl
  • Reinstall: pip uninstall noetl && pip install noetl

Binary Architecture Mismatch:

cannot execute binary file: Exec format error
  • Platform-specific wheel required
  • Install from source: pip install --no-binary noetl noetl

Release Process​

  1. Commit Changes - Push code to master branch
  2. Semantic Release - Analyzes commits, determines version, updates pyproject.toml
  3. GitHub Release - Creates release with tag
  4. Trigger Build - build_on_release.yml workflow activates
  5. Compile Binary - Rust toolchain compiles noetl for target platform
  6. Package Build - uv build creates wheel with embedded binary
  7. PyPI Publish - uv publish uploads to PyPI with authentication token

Migration Notes​

Phase 1: Binary Integration (Completed)​

  • ✅ Rust CLI implemented (noetlctl/src/main.rs)
  • ✅ Docker multi-stage build with Rust compilation
  • ✅ Kubernetes deployments using noetl binary
  • ✅ Local development workflow with ./bin/noetl

Phase 2: PyPI Bundling (Current)​

  • ✅ setuptools-rust configuration in pyproject.toml
  • ✅ GitHub workflow with Rust toolchain setup
  • ⏳ Test PyPI release with bundled binary
  • ⏳ Verify cross-platform installation

Phase 3: Python CLI Removal (Planned)​

  • Remove noetl/cli/ctl.py (Python/Typer implementation)
  • Update noetl/main.py with deprecation notice
  • Remove typer dependency (if unused elsewhere)
  • Update remaining internal references

References​